Research Agenda on School Choice, Part 3: Questions on Private Schools

Feb 16, 2017

This is Part 3 in our series on a new research agenda for school choice. Read Part 1Part 2, and Part 4.

Although there are now a handful of lottery-based (or experimental) studies and strong quasi-experimental studies of the effects of voucher programs on students, the studies’ findings collectively raise more questions than they answer. Moreover, the evidence on the effects of other kinds of private school choice programs is almost nonexistent. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos’ American Federation for Children has supported the trend in many states to promote private school choice through tax-credit-funded voucher programs and K–12 education savings accounts. Arizona and Pennsylvania pioneered tax-credit vouchers, which permit businesses or individuals to take income tax credits for donations to privately operated organizations that provide scholarships that can serve to pay private school tuition. In economic terms, this is equivalent to funding voucher programs directly from state coffers, but it usually means less state regulation of the programs and participating private schools. According to the American Federation for Children, such programs are now operating in 22 states. Meanwhile, five states (again led by Arizona) have created K–12 education savings accounts that enable parents to direct some of the state’s education funding to private school tuition, tutoring, or other educational services or materials. The video below addresses important research questions related to private school choice.

Additional research resources on private school choice programs:

Next post: Research Questions on Online Schooling


The opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and do not represent those of Mathematica Policy Research.

Recent Comments

Join the conversation: You can register for an account to comment on Evidence in Action. Log in to comment through this account or through Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, or Google+.

Log in | Register

View the comments policy

Ed Impact: Comments Policy

We encourage comments on the Ed Impact blog—all viewpoints are welcome. Commenters can register through our simple form to create an account for Ed Impact. Commenters can log in through this account or through their social media accounts. Comments are moderated, and we reserve the right to edit, reject, or remove any that include off-topic statements or links; abusive, vulgar, or offensive content; personal attacks; or spam. Those who violate this policy will be blocked from commenting in the future.

Users who log in through a social media account will be identified by information associated with that account (i.e., a Twitter handle or the user name registered with a Facebook, LinkedIn, or Google+ account). Your comment will not include links to your social media account. Mathematica will not post to your social media account.

Feel free to email us with any questions.